Interaction Design - 2019 - Fintech Hack
Ensuring Financial Wellness for Those with Variable Incomes
Abstract
Fisqual is a tool that empowers freelancers and small businesses to feel financially secure in their independent ventures. The app analyzes freelancers’ income and spending history and calculates a stable monthly income from variable earnings.
Ensuring Financial Wellness for Those with Variable Incomes
UNDERSTAND
ANALYZE
BRAINSTORM
PROTOTYPE
VALIDATE
POST-VALIDATION
The Starving Artist
As designers and art students, many of our peers use freelance as their primary form of income. As a result, they are often plagued with considerable anxiety over the variability of their money flow. Some months may be ripe with client contracts, others may result in a barren checking account. Our first-hand experiences with freelancers pushed Amanda and I to dive deep into the lives of self-employed people. We were inspired to pursue a product-based solution to the struggles faced by people with variable income.
Preliminary Research
Additionally, we consulted studies conducted by outside companies on freelance work, and drew the following statistics of significance.
46%
of respondents pointed out irregular income as the worst part of freelancing
70%
of freelancers are juggling 2 to 4 projects at the same time
77%
of freelancers are less financially stable since ditching their day jobs
63%
of freelancers withdraw from their savings at least once a month
Market Insight
To get a bigger picture for the future of self-employment, we read a study on freelancing conducted by Forbes in 2018. Most statistics pointed to a rapid increase in freelancing within the next decade.
Contextual Inquiry
To research how widespread this postulated problem may be, we sent out a questionnaire around the Maryland Institute College of Art, as well as freelancers that were in our professional network on LinkedIn. We received several responses to the following questions posed:
- As a freelancer, how do you manage your income?
- What tools, if any, do you use for budgeting?
- How much time do you spend creating a budget or managing your finances?
- What adjectives run through your head when you think about budgeting?
- How many freelance gigs are you usually working on simultaneously?
What Freelancers Say
The following are some of the most insightful quotes we have gathered from the aforementioned survey, as well as the interviews.
- We spend about 30 minutes budgeting for our week. — Cindy and Stuart, Freelance Location Scouts
- Budgeting as a freelancer is definitely stressful, but necessary. I often worry about the instability of it. — Katie, Freelance Graphic Designer
- I usually just try to ensure there is some sort of rainy-day fund, and trying to keep my monthly spending in check. — Trevor, Freelance 3D Artist
- Using finance apps, I often forget to input hours, add a client, or lose track of expenses because i don't remember to check it. —Devin, Freelance Product Designer
Selected Responder Interviews
We picked two interviewers who were most vocal about their habits as freelancers and conducted in depth interviews with them for further insight. Amanda took on Devin, a freelance product designer from New York City, while I interviewed Katie, a freelance graphic designer from rural Maryland.
Gaining Insight on the Sentiment of Managing Finances
Discoveries
After conducting questionnaires, interviewing freelance designers and consulting outside sources on the state of self-employment, as well as the future of the market, we concluded the following:
- Freelancers use tools that aren’t designed for financial budgeting.
- Freelancers think making a budget is convoluted, stress inducing and time consuming, but feel like it is completely necessary.
- Freelancers feel big banks don’t meet their unique needs
- The need for freelancers is growing, and there is no one good option for financial management for such a rapidly growing market.
Journey Mapping
Given the discoveries, we created a journey map for the average freelance project to put our findings onto a centralized timeline and analyze possible pain points associated with self-employment.
Design Challenge
How might we ensure financial wellness for self-employed people with variable incomes?
Brainstorming the Scope of the Product
Feature-First Competitive Analysis
We decided to conduct a competitive analysis of existing finance management applications to see how compatible they are with freelance work. The following financial management and budgeting mobile applications were installed and thoroughly researched:
- Acorns — invests the user's spare change by rounding up the purchases they make with a linked credit or debit card.
- Digit — analyzes the user's income and spending patterns, and then automatically dips into the user's checking account and puts a few dollars into a savings account.
- Earnin — lets the user draw small amounts of your earned wages before payday.
- Albert — analyzes user's spending and automatically pulls money from a checking account into a savings account.
- Even — allows the user to get paid on demand and manage their bills.
- Qapital — directs the user to set savings goals and transfers money from checking to savings.
- QuickBooks — allows users who own small businesses send invoices, scan receipts and track their business expenses.
- Hurdlr — helps users track business expenses, income streams, expenses, tax deductions and mileage automatically.
- Mint — syncs to users bank accounts to help track incoming and outgoing money.
- PocketGuard — categorizes and organizes expenses, monthly bills and subscriptions into data visualizations.
Common Features Seen Throughout the Tested Mobile Apps
- Analyzing account information automatically.
- Displaying the amount of money that is Safe to Spend.
- Automatically allocating money to savings accounts.
- Functions for small businesses, such as invoices, expenses, profit and mileage tracking.
- Overviewing multiple accounts, including a business account.
- Getting paid early by collaborating with employers and tracking bills and savings.
- Cashing out before payday, payday loans.
Narrowing Scope
With such a wide spectrum of features, across such a wide spectrum of apps, it is important to keep a narrow scope. With only 24 hours to complete a working prototype and so many possible exploratory paths, we focused on just three principles: centralization, handsfree and adaptability.
Feature Downselection
Keeping the three principles in mind, we’ve narrowed our list of features to the following:
Prototyping an Interface for the Features
Progress-Centric Layout vs. Timeline Centric Layout
A major pivot for the project is whether we want to visualize the data in terms of time or in terms of money. The tree of prototypes below is an exploration of this idea. At the time, the timeline-based view has grown to be more favored by us, because, based on our interviews, freelancers often worded their concerns about living paycheck-to-paycheck.
Validating the Initial Iteration
On-Site User Testing
Once the first iteration was completed, Amanda and I seeked out several testers, which there were plenty of in a hackathon setting. We sat down with several volunteers and had them go through the user flow one by one, jotting down any comments they might have. The following issues became apparent after our user tests:
Information Overload
- What is the graph representing?
- Where do the small buttons go?
- What does the top number mean?
Inconsistent Language
- Confused about Savings vs. Taxes word choice
- Confused about Net Income vs. Budget word choice
Unintuitive Information Architecture
- Confused about Savings vs. Taxes word choice
- Confused about Net Income vs. Budget word choice
Finalizing Design for Judging
Solving Hierarchical Issues
After the user tests, we condensed our concepts into fewer screens, cleaned up our copywriting and re-structured the information architecture:
Winning the Technica 2019 Hackathon
After we finalized our changes, we created an animated prototype using Principle and prepared our pitch. During the judging session, we allowed students, mentors and judges alike try out our product. At the end of the hackathon, it was announced that Fisqual has won the Best Product for Small Businesses award.
